||Kitchener, Waterloo Region, Ontario 
||Kitchener, Waterloo Region, Ontario 
|Weslyan Methodist |
|Eby ID Number
||6 May 1897
||Kitchener, Waterloo Region, Ontario
|Cause: suicide - carolic acid poisoning (2 hours) |
||15 Mar 2017 |
||Andrew Jackson Peterson, b. 12 Dec 1823, , Pennsylvania , d. 7 May 1900, Kitchener, Waterloo Region, Ontario |
||Hannah Armstrong, b. 10 Jul 1825, , England , d. 6 Jan 1904 |
||3 Aug 1845
||Preston (Cambridge), Waterloo Region, Ontario
- PETERSON (Brantford, Ont.) May 11 - The neighbouring villages of Cainsville and Echo Place have been thrown into a great state of excitement over the fact that the guilty man concerned in the betrayal of Miss Nellie Mabel Peterson, of Berlin, who committed suicide on Thursday last, is none other than Mr. Zeigler, a Methodist student at Cainsville, who had been engaged to deceased. As a young man just entering on the work of the ministry he was taken off "the list of reserves" last August to supply a vacancy on the Cainsville circuit and he was so well liked and popular that the congregation recently preferred a unanimous request that he be allowed to continue for another twelve months.
When he heard of the tragedy by telegram, he took a horse and rig with the remark that he was going to Lynden, but instead drove to Onondaga, where he boarded a train for the purpose of getting out of the country. Within the last day or so Mr. Vanderlip, with whom he lived has received from him in Buffalo, stating where the horse and rig could be found, and it is evident that this is the last that will be heard of him.
A charge of immorality has been laid against him, and Rev. Dr. Ross, of this city, chairman of the district, has caused the necessary notices to be served looking towards an inquiry.
In the letter to Mr. Vanderlip, Zeigler stated that he had been walking Buffalo streets in an agony of mind, and did not know whether to make away with himself or not.
(Berlin, Ont.) May 11 - It was very commonly known here that Miss Peterson was engaged to be married to a young Methodist minister named J.A. Zeigler, who received his education at the McGill university, Montreal. He was a native of Berlin, and was taken up by some philanthropically inclined members of the Methodist church in Berlin, and put through college, the object being for him to qualify as a Missionary to China or Japan. He failed to pass his examinations at McGill last summer and was appointed probationally to Kingsley, a little village near Brantford, where he has preached for the past six months or so.
What makes his duplicity and villainy all the more barefaced was a letter from him, which was taken from the post office just about the time of Miss Peterson's death, in which he had advised her not to go to Dr. Honsberger or any other of the Berlin doctors, but rather to see one of the medical men in Waterloo, otherwise, he feared, the matter would leak out.
According to the rules of the Methodist church, a probationer may not marry until he has been ordained. Zeigler, not having been ordained, was afraid that if he married the girl he had betrayed he would be compelled to give up all changes of becoming a Methodist minister.1a
1aHamilton Spectator Wednesday, May 12, 1897
PETERSON (Berlin, Ont.) May 6 - Miss Nellie Peterson, daughter of A.J. Peterson, clerk of the surrogate court here, committed suicide early this afternoon by swallowing a quantity of carbolic acid, which she had purchased during the morning. The other members of the family did not become aware of the young lady's act until it was too late, and she was a corpse before medical aid could be summoned. Miss Peterson was one of the most prominent and popular young ladies in the town, and the news that she had ended her life by her own hand created a great sensation. The cause of the girl's act is as yet unknown.2a
2aHamilton Spectator - Friday, May 7, 1897
- [S158] Census - ON, Waterloo, Berlin - 1881, Div 1 Page 62.